Maná's nomination to the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame has sparked a heated debate in social networks and specialized media. While many celebrate that a Latin band has achieved this recognition, others question whether the Mexican group really belongs to the rock genre.

Too much purism? The discussion has not only put on the table the definition of rock, but also Maná's impact on the Spanish-language music industry.

Be that as it may, Maná has become the first Spanish-language band to receive a nomination for the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, a historic milestone for Spanish-language music. The band, originally from Guadalajara, Mexico, has been successful for almost four decades. Their songs (rock or otherwise) are anthems for many people who remember and know the refrains of songs like "Oye Mi Amor", "Rayando el Sol" and "Labios Compartidos". In addition, Maná has had a real international impact and has collaborated with great artists such as Santana and has filled stadiums not only in America but also in Europe.

What is the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame?

The Rock & Roll Hall of Fame is one of music's most prestigious institutions. Located in Cleveland, Ohio, this museum and organization honors artists, bands and influential figures of the rock genre and its derivatives. To be nominated, an artist must have released his or her first recording at least 25 years earlier and demonstrate a significant impact on the music industry. Over the years, the Hall of Fame has recognized legends such as Elis Presley, The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, Led Zeppelin, Queen and Nirvana.

That is why Maná's nomination to this select list has generated an endless number of reactions. Since the announcement of the nomination, social networks have been a battleground between those who defend Maná's legacy and those who consider that their style is far from rock. Critics and fans have expressed their opinions forcefully.

Music critic Felipe Rodríguez, in an interview with Chile's La Tercera newspaper, stated that "Maná's nomination is not justified; other bands such as Café Tacvba, which is a thousand times better, would be more deserving of this recognition".

El público: Tienen que meter a Soda Stereo en el Salón de la Fama del Rock and Roll por su aporte a la cultura latina.

El Salón de la Fama: Tomamos nota de su reclamo, acá tienen la nominación de MANÁ pic.twitter.com/pn8LEMEezU

— Joaquín Vismara (@joaquinvismara) February 12, 2025

On social networks, comments have also been sharp. One Twitter user ironized: "The public: They have to put Soda Stereo in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame for their contribution to Latin culture. The Hall of Fame: We take note of your claim, here's MANÁ's nomination."

Other musicians have shown their support. Joe Walsh, guitarist for The Eagles and Hall of Fame inductee, commented: "I had the honor of playing with Maná and it was an exciting and fun experience. Even though they sing in Spanish, it doesn't change the fact that they are an incredible rock band that deserves to be in the Hall of Fame."

Maná's legacy

Beyond the discussion about whether or not Maná is a rock band, the truth is that their legacy in Spanish-language music is indisputable. The group has sold more than 40 million albums, toured the world and won multiple awards, including four Grammy Awards and eight Latin Grammy Awards.

Maná is also known for their powerful live performances. They have sold out legendary venues such as Mexico's Foro Sol, where they set a record of 12 consecutive sold-out dates. Their influence on Latin music makes them one of the most important Spanish-speaking bands of all time.

Maná's nomination to the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame marks a before and after for Spanish-language music. Although the debate over their musical stature continues, their impact and legacy are undeniable. With millions of albums sold, massive concerts and a track record of success, Maná remains one of the most influential bands in Latin America. History will tell if they finally make it into this exclusive rock club, but what is certain is that their mark in music is already written. ¡Se canta rock en español!